Klein and Biaggi clash over IDC, Bronx roots and how to help homeless in debate in State Senate primary race
Democratic incumbent State Senator Jeff Klein and primary challenger Alessandra Biaggi answered 30-minutes worth of questions during a debate today on the BronxNet TV network, starting with a hard-hitting query about Klein’s involvement in the recently disbanded Independent Democratic Caucus (IDC) and whether or not it was effective in passing progressive legislation.
Klein said that through the IDC in the State Senate, he was able to raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour and pass the Safe Act, a gun regulation law. Now that the IDC is under the control of the Independence Party, Klein said he does not plan to restart it in the State Senate.
Biaggi replied the group of eight Democrats that voted with the Republicans in the senate “has been a construct that prevented progress for all New Yorkers.”
“Biaggi is pedaling the idea that I pushed for a Republican narrative,” which is not the case, Klein said. Biaggi, in turn, pointed to his acceptance of independent funds, and his vote for an anti-choice candidate against Andrea Stewart-Cousins says otherwise.
The debate, moderated by Gary Axelbank, was televised at 9 p.m. on BronxNet after being taped earlier in the day under the sponsorship of the Bronx Times and the League of Women Voters. Questions were written by the producer of BronxNet TV. The Democratic primary will be held Sept. 13.
Biaggi was asked how she will be able to wield the same clout as Klein given his hold on the seat since 2004. “I intend to represent District 34 by putting the people first,” said Biaggi. She pointed to her previous political work, including her involvement in helping to rebuild New York after Hurricane Sandy, her years spent as an attorney, her time on the Clinton campaign and later in Andrew Cuomo’s office. She returned to the subject of the IDC, jabbing at Klein for what she said were the many progressive bills that didn’t pass during her time in Cuomo’s administration because of the splinter group .
Klein countered that “my opponent has no connection to the Bronx.” He went on to list his achievements in the borough, including his programs to combat gun violence.
“I will not let my opponent disparage that part of my history,” responded Biaggi, who lives in Pelham, in defense of her own Bronx roots.
Both candidates agreed they want the future of the Democratic Party to be diverse. “We as Democrats have a chance to redefine” ourselves, said Klein.
On the issue of the placement of homeless shelters and the general homeless crisis in the 34th District, Biaggi said that people of New York can’t afford to stay in their homes given the price of houses.
“The answer is more housing,” said Klein. He cited his Home Stability Support Program as one way to improve the housing situation in New York. He also noted that he has a lawyer working in his office protecting tenants and making sure they are safe.
Biaggi said that though there are 31 Democrats and 32 Republicans in the New York State Senate, some Republicans will vote for legislation to help on the housing issue.
“Let me know who they are,” said Klein.
Responding to a question on transportation improvement in the district, Klein said, “The Sheridan Expressway needs to change,” adding the roadway should get access to parks and water.
“Parts of the district are transportation deserts,” said Biaggi. “I am in favor of making people’s lives better.” On their thoughts on Mayor Bill de Blasio’s Road Diet Plan—where lanes are reduced—Biaggi said she is on board if it doesn’t hurt traffic, while Klein said the community is against it and so is he.
In his closing statement, Klein said, “I cherish my role as public servant…I was able to get a lot done, and I want to continue to serve the Bronx.”
To finish, Biaggi said, “Government can be used to make the people better…The future of the Democratic Party is diverse, and I am excited to represent all the people of District 34.”
Ella Stern is a freshman at the George Washington University studying journalism and mass communication. Ella's grateful for her experience on the Pelham...